Let’s discuss the mascara that we have all used or desired to use: Better Than Sex Mascara. It’s bold, dramatic, and when it works, it works. You’re not alone, though, if you’ve ever been irritated by how quickly it dries out or how readily it smudges in the middle of the day. Although I was happy with the outcome, I was no longer able to stand up to what had happened. I started looking at alternative choices at that point.
I’ve discovered a few good Better Than Sex Mascara Alternatives that provide me with the same luxurious lash effect without any disappointment after much trial and error and a few blunders. This is something I’ve tried myself and really enjoyed.
My Everyday Favorite:
L’Oréal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Mascara
Why We Love It: This is hands-down the closest alternative I’ve found. The hourglass brush gives incredible volume without clumps.
Brush Shape: Hourglass
Finish: Volumized, flirty lashes with a soft curl
Key Pro: Doesn’t flake, lasts all day
This would be the winner, if I had to choose. I was immediately drawn to the hourglass-shaped brush when I initially opened the container; it’s essentially a twin of the brush from Better Than Sex. I love the lush, fanned-out look that this thick mascara offers and helps coat lashes rapidly.
The thing that shocked me the most was how durable it was. I’ve worn this during a heat wave. It is readily removed with micellar water and does not smudge. To be honest, since switching, I haven’t looked back.
The Definition Queen:
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
Why We Love It: A great everyday pick that makes lashes look naturally long and separated.
Brush Shape: Slim, flexible silicone
Finish: Long, fluttery lashes with zero clumps
Key Pro: Great for layering without getting spidery
Although this isn’t a brush twin, the lift and definition are fantastic. Because of its thinness and flexibility, the wand can reach all of the lashes, including the difficult ones at the corners. It creates the illusion of “my lashes but way better.”
When I want a clean, wide-eyed look without going overboard with the glam, I use this one. Additionally, it’s buildable; I’ve layered it without getting spidery, stiff lashes. That’s rare, especially for a lengthening formula.
Related: The 9 Best Tubing Mascaras for Defined Lashes
Best Budget Pick:
Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
Why We Love It: Delivers serious volume and length without feeling heavy.
Brush Shape: Cone-shaped wand
Finish: Dramatic, full lash line
Key Pro: Budget-friendly, perfect for layering
I gave this one a try to see what all the excitement was about, and now I understand. It’s dramatic, daring, and has a significant effect with only one application. Without the use of glue, the conic brush effectively separates and lifts the lashes to create the appearance of “false lashes.”
When applied lightly, it’s lovely, but if you go crazy, it can get a little clumpy. I always carry one of these with me for emergencies or trips. It’s the most reasonably priced mascara.
Final Thoughts
Too Faced Better Than Sex will always have a place in mascara history, but these alternatives have more than earned their spot in my rotation. Whether you want dramatic volume, clean definition, or a cruelty-free option that holds up all day — there’s something here for every lash mood.
I’ve tested these through daily chaos, humidity, and long nights, and they’ve all impressed me in their own way. If you’re looking to switch it up without sacrificing that bold, lifted lash look, give one (or two) of these a try. They might just surprise you like they did me.
