When we wake up with puffy eyes or notice dark circles settling in, many of us turn to eye balms for relief. Tula Eye Balm is often praised for its cooling effect, hydrating properties, and brightening benefits under the eyes. However, while it’s a fan favorite, it’s not always the most budget-friendly option for everyone, and its formula may not suit all skincare needs.
So, if you’re looking for a Tula Eye Balm alternative, a cooling eye balm alternative, or an under-eye stick alternative that offers similar hydration, de-puffing, and soothing effects, we’ve done the research for you. Below, we explore the best Tula Eye Balm alternatives, providing expert insights on their ingredients and benefits.
Best Tula Eye Balm Alternatives
| Photo | Title | Buy |
|---|---|---|
|
Wet n wild Cooling Hydra De-Puffer | Check Price |
|
Milk Makeup Cooling Water | Check Price |
|
The SAEM Iceland Hydrating Cooling Eye Balm | Check Price |
|
REFY Eye Balm | Check Price |
|
Physicians Formula Eye De-Puffer Stick | Check Price |
As an Amazon Associate, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Alternative #1: Wet n Wild Cooling Hydra De-Puffer
68% Match with Tula in ingredients and function
Match Breakdown:
✔ 55% Ingredient Match
✔ 60% Attribute Match
Why It Works
Wet n Wild’s Cooling Hydra De-Puffer offers an affordable, refreshing alternative to Tula’s under-eye balm, providing an instant cooling sensation and effective puffiness reduction through menthol-based ingredients. While Wet n Wild hydrates and revitalizes with key ingredients like hyaluronic acid and vitamin E, it doesn’t include the same skin-health benefits as Tula’s formula, such as probiotics and caffeine. Tula not only helps to reduce puffiness but also brightens and balances the skin with probiotics, making it a more nourishing option for long-term skin health.
Wet n Wild’s formula, on the other hand, is a quick, budget-friendly solution for those seeking an instant refresh without the advanced skin benefits of Tula. Both are effective, with Wet n Wild being ideal for those looking for an on-the-go, wallet-friendly fix, while Tula is better suited for those wanting a more comprehensive, skin-nourishing under-eye treatment.
Alternative #2: Milk Makeup Cooling Water
70% Match with Tula in ingredients and function
Match Breakdown:
✔ 58% Ingredient Match
✔ 63% Attribute Match
Why It Works
Milk Makeup Cooling Water provides a refreshing and hydrating under-eye experience, offering similar de-puffing benefits to Tula Eye Balm. Infused with caffeine to reduce puffiness and seawater to soothe and hydrate, this vegan and cruelty-free eye gel stick is designed to leave skin feeling energized and refreshed. Unlike Tula, which includes a shimmer effect for a brightening touch, Milk Makeup offers a more natural, matte finish, making it an excellent choice for those who prefer a subtle, non-glittery option.
Its lightweight, gel-based formula absorbs quickly, and it can also be used on the face and body for a quick refresh, especially when stored in the fridge for an extra cooling boost. With no parabens, silicones, oils, alcohol, or gluten, Milk Makeup Cooling Water is perfect for those seeking a clean, cooling solution that hydrates and soothes without added sparkle.
Alternative #3: The SAEM Iceland Hydrating Eye Stick
65% Match with Tula in ingredients and function
Match Breakdown:
✔ 52% Ingredient Match
✔ 60% Attribute Match
Why It Works
The SAEM Iceland Hydrating Eye Stick provides a cooling and hydrating experience, making it a solid alternative to Tula’s eye balm for those seeking a more budget-friendly option. Infused with glacial water and marine extracts, it delivers a refreshing sensation that helps reduce puffiness and soothe the under-eye area. While it lacks the probiotics found in Tula, The SAEM’s formula includes beneficial ingredients like niacinamide, adenosine, and active marine elements, which contribute to hydration and minimizing dark circles and wrinkles.
The lightweight, silky texture and easy-to-apply stick format make it convenient for on-the-go use, and its non-sticky finish ensures it won’t disrupt makeup. Although The SAEM doesn’t offer the same skin-balancing probiotics as Tula Eye Balm, it’s a great choice for those seeking a clean, soothing eye balm with cooling and de-puffing effects, especially for those looking to save on cost without sacrificing performance.
Alternative #4: REFY Eye Balm
72% Match with Tula in ingredients and function
Match Breakdown:
✔ 60% Ingredient Match
✔ 65% Attribute Match
Why It Works
REFY Eye Balm is a nourishing alternative to Tula, providing hydration and soothing benefits through its squalane and peptide-rich formula. While it lacks the cooling sensation of Tula’s formula, it excels in long-term hydration and skin benefits. The balm contains hyaluronic acid, which helps attract and retain moisture, promoting plumper skin, while floral water calms and soothes the under-eye area. REFY’s balm-essence hybrid is designed to moisturize thoroughly and reduce the appearance of dark circles, puffiness, and fine lines over time.
Its solid stick format makes for quick, easy application, and it rapidly melts into the skin for a smooth, cooling effect that refreshes the under-eye area, making it an excellent choice for those seeking lasting hydration and skin rejuvenation without the immediate cooling sensation Tula provides.
Alternative #5: Physicians Formula Eye De-Puffer Stick
67% Match with Tula in ingredients and function
Match Breakdown:
✔ 54% Ingredient Match
✔ 58% Attribute Match
Why It Works
Physicians Formula RefreshMint Cucumber & Bamboo Eye De-Puffer Stick offers a cooling, hydrating, and soothing under-eye treatment similar to Tula’s balm. Infused with natural ingredients like cucumber, bamboo extract, aloe vera, and peppermint, it provides a refreshing sensation that helps reduce puffiness and dark circles, making it a great choice for those seeking a gentle, natural alternative. The addition of glacial mineral water and hydrating bamboo shoot further nourishes the skin, while its hypoallergenic, fragrance-free formula ensures it’s safe for sensitive skin.
Although it doesn’t have the probiotics or caffeine found in Tula, it’s an excellent budget-friendly option for those who prefer a cooling eye balm with natural ingredients. Its cooling effect can be enhanced by storing it in the fridge, providing an extra-refreshing boost.
Final Thoughts: Which Tula Eye Balm Alternative is Best for You?
Each of these options provides hydration, cooling effects, and depuffing benefits without the premium price tag. If you’re looking for an identical cooling sensation, the Wet n Wild Cooling Hydra De-Puffer and Milk Makeup Cooling Water are great picks. If you prefer hydration with a Korean skincare twist, The SAEM Iceland Hydrating Eye Stick is an excellent choice.
These alternatives make it easy to enjoy the benefits of Tula’s Glow & Get It Eye Balm in a way that fits your needs and budget.
Whether you prioritize cooling, hydration, or skin-soothing ingredients, there’s an option here that can seamlessly fit into your routine. Try one and experience refreshed, revitalized under-eyes!
